
WAR WITH IRAQ IS NOT THE ANSWER
by Father John Dear, S. J.
Heading to war with Iraq is a grave
mistake. It can only lead to catastrophic consequences for the suffering
people of Iraq, other suffering people around the world and ourselves.
Since 1990, our sanctions on Iraq have killed over one million Iraqis,
over half of them children under five, according to UNICEF, the
World Health Organization, the Vatican and the United Nations. These
dying Iraqi children were born long after the 1991 Gulf war, have
suffered under Saddam, but die because of our sanctions and bombs.
No one supports tyranny in Iraq
or anywhere, but bombing these suffering people will not bring democracy,
just further their unimaginable suffering. Bombing Iraq will only
make matters worse; it may lead even to the use of nuclear weapons,
and set a horrible global precedent, that it is okay to bomb preemptively.
I have been to Iraq and seen
for myself the effects of our sanctions and bombing raids. In March
1999, I led a delegation of Nobel peace prize winners to Baghdad.
We met with religious leaders, United Nations and non-governmental
organization officials, and even government representatives, but
most importantly, we saw with our own eyes the reality of the suffering
these sanctions have caused. We saw hundreds of children dying of
relievable diseases, because we have systematically destroyed Iraq’s
infrastructure.
There are many reasons why we
should not attack Iraq. A war aimed at “regime change”
is unjust, unwise, and incompatible with any criteria for establishing
long lasting peace. Again, this could set a precedent with unbelievable
ramifications.
The Bush administration has
offered no evidence of any links between Saddam Hussein and the
terrorist attacks of 9/11. There is no evidence that Iraq currently
has useable weapons of mass destruction.
The best way to security and
peace in the region continues to be through the United Nations,
the UN-administered process of weapons inspections, and a strategy
of regional disarmament (as called for in UN Security Council Resolution
687, article 14).
An attack on Iraq will further
alienate U.S. allies and dramatically increase anti-American sentiment
throughout the world.
War with Iraq will hurt our
already failing economy. Instead of funding jobs, healthcare, schools,
low-income housing, environmental clean-up, and balancing the budget,
we will be paying billions more to kill Iraqi children.
Most critically, preemptive
war is illegal under international law. Once one country takes preemptive
action, other countries will follow suit. If the U.S. bombs Iraq,
and calls it self-defense, we can be assured that similar wars will
break out else. We will have set a very bad example, one that could
lead to the death of literally millions of innocent people on every
continent.
In the end, we should not go
to war because it risks the lives of thousands of U.S. soldiers
and hundreds of thousands of Iraqi civilians, beginning with the
already suffering, innocent children.
There are many alternatives
to war, they just require patience and hard work. Making peace throughout
the world is much harder than war, and requires long-term vision.
Instead of trying to overthrow any government, we should root out
the causes of terrorism, starting with global poverty, widespread
Øø starvation, and weapons sales. We should lift all
economic sanctions on Iraq and impose strict military sanctions
not only on Iraq, but throughout the Mid-East.
Bombing the children of Iraq
will not solve our problems or grant us security or bring us peace
or save us from terrorist attacks or help the world. It will protect
the oil companies’ bank accounts, take our minds off our failing
economy and sow the seeds for further terrorism.
Before moving to New Mexico
this summer to serve as a pastor of several churches here in the
desert, I worked in New York city as a Red Cross coordinator of
chaplains at the Family Assistance Center, and counseled thousands
of grieving relatives and exhausted rescue workers. I have seen
up close the grief that comes from massive violence.
Most New Yorkers know that bombing
Iraq, just like bombing Afghanistan, is not going to bring back
our loved ones or protect us from further attacks. In fact, it will
inflame millions more people around the world against us, and guarantee
further terrorist attacks against us.
War with Iraq is not only illegal
and immoral, it’s just downright impractical. It’s not
justified or noble, just stupid and lethal.
From a Christian perspective,
war is never blessed by God. It is never the will of God. It is
always a mortal sin. Christians are called to love our enemies,
not bomb them. Anyone who claims to be a Christian and supports
the bombing of the children of Iraq has renounced their faith. They
are practicing the ultimate form of child abuse.
At the end of our journey to
Iraq, Nobel peace prize winner Mairead Corrigan Maguire from Northern
Ireland said, “Fifty years from now, the next generation will
ask, ‘What were you doing when the children of Iraq were dying?’”
Let’s rule out bombing
Iraq as an option, refuse to kill any more innocent Iraqi children,
and start developing a new way to live nonviolently with the rest
of the world.
- Fahter John Dear, S. J.
John Dear, S.J. is pastor
of Catholic churches in Springer, Cimarron, Angel Fire, Maxwell,
Palo Blanco and Eagle Nest, New Mexico, and author, most recently,
of LIVING PEACE (Doubleday) and editor of MOHANDAS GANDHI: ESSENTIAL
WRITINGS (Orbis).
back to home
page
|